Case study
Three ads had been running for more than a year and results decayed a little every month. We built a testing system a direct to consumer skincare brand runs on its own, so a new idea reaches customers the same week somebody has it.
Named only with client approval Figures marked are illustrative Reply within one business day
Attribution · this quarter
GA4 · server-side312
Booked calls
3.1x
ROAS
−31%
CPL
OlDevs built a paid social creative testing system that a direct to consumer skincare brand now runs itself, replacing a rotation of three long running ads with a shot list mapped to five message angles, a naming convention that carries angle, hook and format into Meta Ads Manager, and a fixed weekly edit day.Tests run in their own campaign and winners graduate into evergreen ad sets rather than being rebuilt from scratch. A Looker Studio board reads results by angle, so the team learns which idea works instead of which file performed. The brand now ships 18 new concepts per month, with cost per acquisition down 37 percent and return on ad spend at 2.4x.
Key facts
The challenge
Paid social had settled into three ads that had been running for more than a year, and results decayed a little every month. New creative appeared only when the budget cycle allowed it, so there was never enough volume to learn what genuinely worked. The brand had a studio's worth of raw footage sitting unused and no method for turning it into tests.
The same three ads had been in market for more than a year. Response fell month after month, and the account needed more spend to hold the same result, because there was nothing tested and waiting to take over.
New creative was commissioned only when a budget cycle allowed it, so tests arrived in occasional bursts. There was never enough in market at once to separate a genuine winner from a lucky week, and the learning never accumulated.
A shoot had produced hours of perfectly usable material that sat in a folder. Nothing connected that raw footage to a message the brand wanted to test, so the library aged while the account ran the same three ads.
Ad names were file names, so reporting could say which asset spent well but never why it won. The team could not tell whether a result came from the hook, the format or the claim, so nothing useful carried into the next round.
What we built
We built a creative testing system the brand runs itself: a shot list mapped to five message angles, a naming convention that carries angle, hook and format straight into Meta Ads Manager, and a fixed weekly edit day that ships a set number of new concepts. Tests run in their own campaign with a clean structure, and winners graduate into evergreen ad sets rather than being rebuilt from scratch. A Looker Studio board reads results by angle, so the team learns which idea works instead of which file performed.
We defined five angles the brand can argue credibly, then wrote a shot list against each one so every shoot produces material for a specific test rather than generic footage somebody has to find a purpose for later.
Angle, hook and format travel in the ad name straight into Meta Ads Manager and out into reporting, so every impression is attributable to an idea. Nothing has to be tagged by hand afterwards and no result arrives without its context.
One fixed day each week turns existing footage into a set number of finished concepts. That cadence is how the account reached 18 new concepts per month without waiting on a budget cycle or booking another studio shoot.
Tests run in their own campaign with clean structure and budgets, and proven concepts graduate into evergreen ad sets carrying their learning history instead of being rebuilt from scratch and starting cold in a new ad set.
Process
Angle workshop
We worked with the brand's growth and marketing leads to define five message angles the brand can defend, each with the audience it speaks to and the objection it answers.
Footage audit and shot list
We catalogued the existing studio footage against those angles, found where the gaps were, and wrote a shot list so future shoots produce material for named tests.
Naming and account structure
We rebuilt the Meta account with a dedicated test campaign, a clean ad set structure and a naming convention that carries angle, hook and format into every report.
Weekly edit cadence
We set a fixed edit day, a target number of concepts per week and a simple queue, so the team always knows what is being cut, reviewed and shipped next.
Read by angle, then graduate winners
Each week the Looker Studio board is read by angle rather than by file, losing concepts are cut, and proven ones move into evergreen ad sets with their history intact.
Stack
Paid social
Creative production
Measurement
Workflow
18
New concepts shipped per month
−37%
Cost per acquisition
2.4x
Return on ad spend
Outcomes
Creative volume is now a rhythm rather than an event, so the account always has something tested and ready when an ad tires.
Fresh creative in market at a steady rate stopped the monthly decay that had been quietly making every customer more expensive.
Winners graduate into evergreen ad sets with their history intact instead of restarting cold, so proven ideas keep earning.
Reporting by angle tells the brand which argument persuades people, which is knowledge that survives every individual ad going stale.
In their words
We can put a new idea in front of customers the same week somebody has it.
Head of growth, direct to consumer skincare brand
Consumer goods, beauty
FAQ
Five is enough to cover the main reasons people buy and few enough that each angle collects data worth reading. Testing everything at once produces results nobody can act on, because no single idea gets the volume it needs to prove itself. Angles also give you something to carry forward when a specific ad eventually tires.
The shot list is written against the angles, so the next shoot has a brief before it starts and produces material for named tests. Between shoots the weekly edit day keeps producing new cuts, hooks and formats from existing material, which is where most of the monthly concept volume came from without any new production.
It is the difference between knowing which file spent well and knowing which idea worked. Angle, hook and format travel in the ad name into Meta Ads Manager and out into the Looker Studio board, so reporting groups results by idea automatically and nobody has to tag anything by hand after the numbers land.
Your team does, and that was the point from the first week. The shot list, naming convention, edit day cadence, campaign structure and reporting board are documented and handed over. Clients own all code, designs, accounts and IP on every OlDevs engagement, so nothing here is locked to us staying involved.
A concept graduates when it clears an agreed threshold across enough spend, not on the strength of one good day. It then moves into an evergreen ad set that keeps its history rather than being rebuilt from scratch, so it does not start cold, and the test campaign stays clean for the next round of concepts.
Let’s connect
Tell us what is not working. We’ll reply within one business day with how we would approach it and a tailored quote.